Unearthing Realities: Product Capability vs Current Market Positioning - What to Choose

Helping our Private Equity client assess the capabilities and market positioning of four leading delivery management platform providers and support their 8-figure investment decision.

Our Client’s Problem
General Partners (GPs) and analyst teams at private equity firms face a common problem: How does one assess the relative value of any given investment before before making it? 

Our client was considering making an 8-figure investment into a top-tier delivery management platform provider. With a myriad of choices in a rapidly growing market, the stakes were high. The question wasn't merely about product market fit or growth but understanding the true capabilities of the delivery management platform and the value offered by alternatives.
 

Our Brief
The task set before us was clear-cut: Conduct a deep analysis of four leading delivery management platform providers, ensuring that we are going beyond the "data room" of the vendor they were interested in acquiring. Our client aimed to uncover the real strengths, weaknesses, and market positioning of the solutions offered by these players, so as to have a clear view of where they should be putting their bets on.
 

To achieve this, we were to engage in interviews, particularly targeting ex-executives of these platform providers to gain technical information and market insights that were unfiltered and genuine.
 

Our Method
Transparency and Verifiability stand as pillars at 4D. Taking on a project of this magnitude, we embarked on an exhaustive search, identifying ex-executives and key stakeholders who had a pulse on these platforms' operations, market strategies and solution capabilities. After narrowing down to a list of over 60 potential interviewees from the four platform providers, we successfully conducted in-depth interviews with 12 ex-executives.

To ensure the authenticity of the information and instill confidence of our client, we rigorously scrubbed any sensitive Personally Identifiable Information (PII) and shared our interview recordings. This unprecedented level of transparency was appreciated by our client, reinforcing the credibility of our findings.

Client Outcomes
From the insights we gathered, a few startling realities surfaced:
 

1. Limited Integration Capabilities: One of the platform providers, although among the market leaders, faced significant challenges with third-party integrations. This limitation hindered its scalability for retail customers looking to seamlessly incorporate various external tools.
    

2. Inconsistent User Experience: Another platform vendor, while boasting substantial clients and orders, had persistent issues with user experience consistency. Feedback from users highlighted intermittent system glitches and un-intuitive interfaces.
    

3. Marketing Over Reality: A recurrent theme from our interviews was the disparity between the marketed capabilities of these platforms and their actual functionality. One platform, in particular, promised advanced AI-driven delivery routing but failed to deliver on this promise in real-world scenarios.
    

4. Unsustainable Pricing Models: The fourth platform's aggressive pricing model, while initially attracting a substantial user base, was found by us to be unsustainable in the long run, raising concerns about its future viability.
    

Given these findings, our client was equipped with a multi-dimensional view of the market landscape. While the market projections and figures in the vendor data room painted a rosy picture, the operational realities revealed by our due diligence highlighted genuine technical concerns that the acquiree was not addressing in its product roadmap.
 

Guided by our insights, our client decided to approach the acquisition with caution, choosing to further negotiate terms and ensure mitigation strategies for our highlighted issues. 
 

This proved invaluable, as our client was able to avoid pitfalls and make a more informed valuation decision. With private valuations also falling in 2022 and 2023, our client's patience together with our due diligence paid off. They were able to make a tremendous acquisition at a significant discount and mitigate the technical risks of their investment.

​